Keep or return 1917 holster

[milesc2]

I bought this holster on gunbroker for $175 including shipping.
The seller did not disclose or photograph the damage to the toe or mag pouch area. I requested high res photos but they still did not show the damage. I also requested a photo of the mag pouch but he mananged to take one from a good angle.
The strap also looks to be a replacement and it has a few other minor issues.

For $175 would you keep or return this holster?
($155 if you count the $20 shipping loss)

Thanks,
-Miles