Should I restore 1941 Luger

[4 Scale]

Originally Posted by MaxTaste

I am considering a full restoration or a deep cleaning. I e heard full restorations will reduce the value. This fully original piece is something I’d like to have as a show piece.

Pros and cons of full restoration including paint?

To clarify and make a final attempt to help you with your decision:

As this thread shows, collectors prize fully original examples and are loath to restore those. The best course for most folks most of the time who want a cosmetically impressive example is to buy an original finish, high-condition pistol. If you restore, you will not recover the cost, you may actually decrease value and the collector value of the pistol will be gone.

In your case, if you want a nicer cosmetic example, the best course is likely to sell what you have and apply the funds toward a nicer original example.

The most advisable course of learning for newer collectors is first, buy a 'shooter' grade gun with mismatched parts and/or refinish, shoot it, and get to know the type. Then, buy high quality books and read. This will help you figure out where your interests lie. Then, purchase one or more all-original examples that satisfy your now-informed interests and tastes. Of course you can try to shortcut this process but will then run the risk of expensive mistakes, AKA "Luger University Tuition". Don't ask me how I know this.

IMO newer collectors especially should avoid the restoration question, too many pitfalls and complexities and risk of destroying a piece that should be left alone.

Finally, all of this is almost pure speculation as we have not seen pictures of the pistol in question. Best of luck to you and I hope you post photos and let us know your decision.