Need help identifying/assessing P08

[4 Scale]

Originally Posted by ct11b

..what accounts for the mismatched parts ex. the "75" and as you stated 1912 over the chamber, and S / 42 above toggle?

His background story is that, it's his grandfather's take home, war trophy from WW2.

Seems logical enough for me to assume that due to it being a Luger, but could very well be a gun show, pawn shop pick up?

S/42 was code indicating the manufacturer (Mauser).

Just like some cars, Lugers are often cannibalized for parts as pistols age or components break. It is not uncommon to see a pistol like this one, assembled from several guns.

It's also common for Lugers to be come with stories intended to enhance value. Unless well documented, most collectors advise to ignore the story and evaluate the gun strictly on its merits.

Function is always a question on mismatched pistols. I also think new Luger owners should not pay for valuable accessories like holsters until they have a feel for where their interests lie. Given the poor cosmetics, quantity of mismatched parts, inclusion of a holster and high initial price I don't think this is good first Luger for anyone.