studying books and forum pays off

[jeb111]

Went to a gun show this weekend in MT. It was small but did find a table w/ about 12 Lugers. Seller gave me his card, Luger collector and WW1 WW2 militaria. Had a nice 1906 American Eagle with visible matching #'s incorrect mag, and a nice Erfurt w/ all matching #'s incl, mag. Question, is it unreasonable to ask to confirm matching #'s by disassembling pistol? Seller said it could "mess up gun". I had a pocket full of cash so I was a serious buyer. Main reason for post is that all the research from this forum and taking the advice of reading books really paid off as I knew what to look for and what I was looking at. Seller also had a Stoeger artillery but I didn't bother looking too closely at it as the seller didn't seem to keen on showing it.
Jim

[mikedavid]

By him not wanting to disassemble it so you can check to see if it's all matching, would send off a red flag to me!

[Neil Young]

If he was a Luger collector, he certainly knows how to disassemble the pistol and certainly knows that it will not "mess up the gun". So, in my book, the least he did was lie to you and probably tried to pass off a mismatched Luger for a collector price. Smile and walk away--no, run away.

[DavidJayUden]

I would think that an honest and serious seller would be willing to prove that it is truly matching in order to get a sale. How about, "Here's my money, show me it is matching in and out and you have a sale".
I know I'd be all over that one...
We just have to bear in mind all the non-serious tire kickers that are drawn to Lugers.
dju

[wlyon]

I will not let people at gun shows disassemble my guns. However if the person is serious I will take them apart and show him/her the numbers. If some one has a table of lugers and will not take them apart I would be very suspicious. Bill

[Norme]

Checking ALL the numbered parts on an Erfurt could be somewhat time consuming and I can understand why the seller might be reluctant to let you have at it if the show is busy. The following parts can be checked without disassembly:
Frame, Barrel, Receiver, Extractor, Middle toggle, Rear toggle, Side-plate, Sear bar, Safety bar, Take-down lever, Safety lever and Magazine.
Checking the following require disassembly:
"Hidden number" on side-plate, Trigger, Breech-block, Firing pin, Hold-open and both Grips.
Norm

[Edward Tinker]

A tear down will show everything but the grip markings. Not sure how an Erfurt or Simson would be an issue Norm?

Anyway, I have taken down many a luger to show somebody - but I sure prefer them to be more than a tire-kicker - After a few unsuccessful tire kickers, I usually say something like, and after talking a bit, "sure we can take it down and check everything".
.
.

BUT, the line about taking them apart and this could mess them up - I bet they are not HIS but someone else's.

[lugerholsterrepair]

I won't let just anyone monkey with any Luger I have OR hold a holster. Too many people are just ham fisted knuckleheads with no respect for antiques. You can't tell who is who. I found out years ago if you hand a holster to someone they immediately peer, poke and prod into it like they are looking for a hidden hundred dollar bill. No care taken. So I NEVER hand out a holster to anyone but a trusted collector.



But I agree with the above..the dealer should open up any specific pistol to get a look at the insides. "Here's my money, show me it is matching in and out and you have a sale". sure sounds reasonable to me! Especially on a $2,500+ purchase.

[Edward Tinker]

Originally Posted by lugerholsterrepair

....

But I agree with the above..the dealer should open up any specific pistol to get a look at the insides. "Here's my money, show me it is matching in and out and you have a sale". sure sounds reasonable to me! Especially on a $2,500+ purchase.

Unless the 12 lugers were $499 each and then I would just pull out my credit card and say, do I get a discount for 12?

[jcoe]

Jim, there are a lot of “private sale” guys here in Montana, quite independent folks, who enjoy a relatively unencumbered sale in most of the state, and will not bother with paper work for an out-of-state buyer. As already noted, purchase of an unexamined P08 is like buying a pig in a poke.
BRegs, John

[jeb111]

My main reason for the post was to point out how much researching books and this forum has been beneficial in looking to buy another Luger. I also think looking at lots Lugers in person really is where a guy learns. I was glad to encounter this seller, he was friendly and willing until it seemed that I was somewhat knowledgeable. I never asked or presumed if I could disassemble the pistols and never come off as a know it all but if a guy is asking IMO top dollar for as he said all matching # gun then prove it. I had money, told him I was a serious buyer and wasn't wasting time. He did say he would bring the pistol to an FFL holder in my hometown to sell to me so he offered options to me as an out of stater.

Jim

[mrerick]

If someone represents themselves as a "Luger Collector", it's reasonable to assume that they have the ability to disassemble field strip a Luger. To the extent possible, if I were selling a matching Luger, and a serious buyer was ready to make an offer that I would accept, I would be happy to sit down, take out a mat and show the buyer the matching parts I could access.

If a seller was unwilling to do that, I would simply offer them a price for the pistol as a "shooter", and tell them that if they wanted anywhere near to a "collectible Luger" price, I need to see the matching numbers and condition of internal parts.

if you are inexperienced at disassembling firearms, never ask a seller to let you take them apart.

[Big Fish]

Forum membership paid off for myself this weekend past, the seller was offering a friends luger.
I told everything I knew about it and showed him a few things and thanked him, went on my way.
A few hours later I bumped into him again but left with pistol in hand this time.

Moral, knowledge and honesty makes a grand deal for both parties. Cheers.

[RDS]

Another thing to consider. Even if the gun matches you have to check the condition of the firing pin. I worked in the industry back in the late 80s and most of the 90s.It was a time when WWII vets reached retirement age, were moving out of the greater NYC area and heading south. A good number of the guns that they brought into us to sell had broken off firing pin tips or no firing pin. The story was always the same. "I picked this up in the war but when the kids came along my wife made me remove the firing pin and I don't remember where I put it" or "I took the firing pin to work and ground the tip off to keep the wife happy. Sad but true.

[gunnertwo]

True story on the FP. One of my treasures is a S&W Victory that was given to me by a Naval Aviator that was on the USS Bunker Hill when hit by a Kamikaze. He had clipped off the tip of the FP due to the grand kids. A trip to my local 'smith fixed that. He also gave me the USN marked shoulder holster that had his name and squadron - VT-84.

G2