Magazine comparasion webpage

[Edward Tinker]

In answer to a new members questions, I finally thought, lets just do it.

Question was; is there a site that shows various magazines for lugers?

Answer: Not yet, so lets do it! There should be a web page that shows the many types.

If folks send me pictures of as many types as they have, I will collate and make a webpage on this.

weimar_lugers@comcast.net

What I need:

You will need to take pictures of each side, spine and base, then tell me what it is, because I am an idiot when it comes to figuring out magazines. I am fairly good at collating information and have the time right now.

Ed

[Silvereagle29]

Ed
I notice on another website that you are confusing early Haenal magazines with the late - y - block fxo magazines. The first extruded type spine marked Haenel-Schmeisser magazines went to the G-S/42 Police Lugers in October of 1935. They will have a script - H - on the base. The SB K and others came later. Don't be confused by a note that the Police Dove came in 1921. Actually it appeared in early 1936.
Good luck

[LU1900]

...........

[Silvereagle29]

LU1900
A picture would be nice
Thanks

[LU1900]

...........

[Edward Tinker]

Originally Posted by Silvereagle29

Ed
I notice on another website that you are confusing early Haenal magazines with the late - y - block fxo magazines. The first extruded type spine marked Haenel-Schmeisser magazines went to the G-S/42 Police Lugers in October of 1935. They will have a script - H - on the base. The SB K and others came later. Don't be confused by a note that the Police Dove came in 1921. Actually it appeared in early 1936.
Good luck

hmmmm, I don't disbeleive you, but I asked several folks and nobody else thought the dove was that late?

Why would the nazi acceptance have gone back to a dove looking acceptance marking when they were using stick / droop eagles?

Ed

[Silvereagle29]

Ed
I suppose the real issue may be the Military appearing Dove and what collectors have labeled the bird looking dove as found on the C.G Haenel magazines. I certainly agree with you the Military Dove is from the early 1920's. The dove that I refer to appeared on the extruded C.G Haenel (Haenel - Schmeisser) magazines of early 1936. This dove on Police magazines is comparable to the sunburst K, D, Haenel script - H - EL, EF and other marks that may be found on Police magazines. None of these marks are normally found on Military magazines. If one were to compare the early Military dove and the Police dove they don't even look alike. In my opinion, we have to think Military vs Police. I will take some pictures of the Haenel Police Luger magazines and mail them to you.

The magazines going to the Military were accepted by the Inspectors using the drooped Eagle and Stick Eagle. Usually those going to the Police from Mauser had no acceptance mark. I lean toward the thought that the fxo magazines with the x and y suffix with all the Military acceptance marks were given to the Police when Mauser severly curtailed the numbering of Luger magazines in the - u - block of the 41-byf production.

The Police had a long standing relationship with the C.G. Haenel Company and received most of there magazine from them. The G-S/42 and 1936-S/42 Lugers with the sear safety are good examples. They left Mauser with no accessories, not even a magazine. The magazines used on these pistols were the first spine marked extruded magazine with the Haenel script - H - and came directly from C.G. Haenel to the Prussian Police depot, the - H - on the heal of the Police Haenel magazine would date these magazines to near October of 1935. Once again this is only my opinion.

I suspect we have been exposed to a little lack of communication on my part, sorry about that.

Don

[Edward Tinker]

hmmm, interesting, I agree the dove from the 20's and the later Haenel doves look totally different.



Ed

[Chickenthief]

Did this happen?

[rpbcps]

Originally Posted by Edward Tinker

In answer to a new members questions, I finally thought, lets just do it.

Question was; is there a site that shows various magazines for lugers?

Answer: Not yet, so lets do it! There should be a web page that shows the many types.

If folks send me pictures of as many types as they have, I will collate and make a webpage on this.

weimar_lugers@comcast.net

What I need:

Ed

A sticky showing, chronologically, the various magazines manufactured for lugers, highlighting the developments in manufacturing, with markings and stamps used, would be a really useful tool for forum members.

Richard