1920 Carbine, Less Forearm

[lugerholsterrepair]

John, Very well done! You have pretty much covered this subject. Not much is put together on civilian guns..No books I know of. Charles Whittaker at the Land of Borchardt is a very fine Gentleman and very knowledgeable. Good job! The only other variations I know of might be the Pacific Arms guns. I actually owned a Pacific Arms Carbine with a forearm once years ago..They likely made or put together long barreled guns with and without forearms.

[Dick Herman]

I was traveling when this thread was posted, so I was unable to put in my 2 cents. For what it is worth here is my observation and opinion.

Both the Jones and Kenyon reference books have been around for a very long time. Their information is useful and has been used and accepted be more contemporary authors. The 1920ish Luger carbine without a fore stock has been referenced since a time when there were fewer collectors and values that did not encourage counterfeiting.

One of the reasons for the fore stock spring assist on the 1902 carbines was the weaker leaf main spring. Due to the reciprocating mass of the 1902 carbine barrel and toggle top assembly the leaf main spring did not provide enough force for complete closure. The fore stock spring assist provided the additional force for complete battery closure. The later coil main spring provided enough force for complete battery.

What I am presenting here is a Model 1923ish Commercial American Eagle Carbine without a fore stock. The frame is marked Safe and the extractor is marked Loaded. The 11 3/4" Barrel with an adjustable rear sight is 7.65mm Parabellum. As stated above there is no Fore Stock. The serial number is 91273. Small parts have matching numbers. Proof marks are C/N. Country of origin, Germany, is marked in several places.

[Dick Herman]

1920 Carbine W/O Fore Stock

[Dick Herman]

1920 Carbine with out fore stock