LugerForum Discussion Forums - View Single Post

drbuster · 12-28-2003, 11:05 PM

Ron raises several sigificant and interesting questions regarding this piece. If it is a restoration, it was very well done. I agree that the grips have a little wear, but the blue and straw are 100%. I recently inspected another presentation 1900 piece, the deAlvear luger. It too, was 100% and the grips looked also 100%. There was no "GL" proof and the serial number was below 10,000. It did not sell on a recent Andrew Martin auction as the reserve price was not met. What is a "serious" collector to do? Whom do we trust? This Pheonix Arms 1900 is probably priced over $20000. It would probably be worth it IF original. But then how can one tell? We need documentation. I guess that's why Ralph's consignment .45 carbine hasn't sold. Just my humble opinion.

12-28-2003, 11:05 PM	#3
drbuster User Join Date: Jun 2002 Location: San Mateo, California Posts: 1,432 Thanks: 2 Thanked 71 Times in 56 Posts	Ron raises several sigificant and interesting questions regarding this piece. If it is a restoration, it was very well done. I agree that the grips have a little wear, but the blue and straw are 100%. I recently inspected another presentation 1900 piece, the deAlvear luger. It too, was 100% and the grips looked also 100%. There was no "GL" proof and the serial number was below 10,000. It did not sell on a recent Andrew Martin auction as the reserve price was not met. What is a "serious" collector to do? Whom do we trust? This Pheonix Arms 1900 is probably priced over $20000. It would probably be worth it IF original. But then how can one tell? We need documentation. I guess that's why Ralph's consignment .45 carbine hasn't sold. Just my humble opinion.