[lugerholsterrepair]

GT..A man if your highly technical skills and knowledge must be respected for his opinion. The Trommel magazine..compared to say the .32 round MP40 stick magazine is incredibly complex and fragile there is no doubt. The metal is likely soft as you say but strong as it needs to be under even harsh conditions. That's proven as they have survived quite well for right at 100 years. Like any other complex mechanical delivery system they must be well taken care of, maintained and kept in good order to work well.
I think I find their charm is in exactly what is stated above..Same for the Luger really. Highly complex..some might say over engineered and finicky..all good reasons to love and cherish them for what they are. They will last with care and they are really fun toys! Everytime I pick one up I am in awe of the history held in my hands..It is a priviledge to be fortunate enough to own these things.