Ed,
I suppose that when a M1906 Portugese Royal Navy Luger in this mint condition comes out of Portugal (which is in my collection) - most people would either say it is suspicious or fake? Do you think that the straw is a bit on the strong side? If you have any doubt, you can ask Ron for his expert opinion who has examined this Luger in his hands.
In my opinion, when a couple of collectors on this forum rushed to judgement regarding the M1900 Commercial that Pepe located in Portugal based on average quality images, I felt that it was a wrong move until he provided better images. The flaw on the (left) grip was probably the first indication that there was tampering, however, it always better to ask for quality images until giving an opinion. Images can often be misleading or inaccurate, so learn to be careful.
Eventhough my opinion may not be complete, I prefer to give a final opinion when there is an opportunity to examine the item inhand.
In regards to my 'rudness' or arrogance, at times I have a reason to be because some people 'just don't get it' (i.e. M1906 Russian Contract and pre-production Lugers). Some people do not have any idea how commercial and army contract business operated in the early 1900's in regards to German firearms. For example, the Russian Army ordering pistols with Bulgarian markings and an emblem that makes no connection to the Russian empire - explain that one to me. All I hope is that some people will start to use their brain and common sense by learning to understand the heritage, standards and rules of other nations.
Albert
|