Hello Ron,
Over the years, I have moved away from those 'defined' serial ranges mentioned in various books, especially those relating to the Mauser C96. As I continue to examine more guns in my hands in various countries of the world which gives me the opportunity to increase my expertise, these 'outside' guns are allowing me to make some exceptions to the rule. These exceptions which I consider and accept are not made based on the discovery of only one pistol, but at least three which must be genuine/original.
In regards to the US Test Trials Luger being discussed in this topic, it is very likely that it has been professionally restored (and a damn good one), so this pistol in my opinion cannot be classified as an 'exception' when comparing it to Bannerman records. If the Bannerman records state that the pistols 7108 and 7149 are Test Lugers, then the next story we will hear is that there were 39 additional pistols purchased by Bannerman from the US Government.
In a previous discussion on the serial range of the US Test Trial pistols (including their characteristics), I continue to notice that controversary still exists on the subject of the true serial range and I would not classify those pistols that fall outside the 6100-7100 serial range by 10-20 numbers as true US Trial Lugers, especially when some details are not specific such as serial number location on the takedown lever.
If I was going to spend $14k on a US Test Trials Luger, I would want it to be in the 6100-7100 serial range as well as having the EXACT characteristics of a true US Trials Luger. If other collectors wish to gamble against these strong facts, that is their freedom of choice.
Albert
|