Barb,
You have been given the correct information about the military use of this style of holster and the appropriate model of Luger it would carry. The advice is also correct about it being a reproduction. Together with the answers you received on the Gunboards forum, the combined experience of the individuals that replied is well over 100 years, and probably closer to 200 years, of collecting.
It is unfortunate that you purchased a reproduction as an original. But since you bought it from an antique dealer, chances are good that they were also unaware that it is a repro. You would not expect to have an antique Victorian writing desk purchased from a sporting goods store to be absolutely authentic. If the dealers are as reputable as you think, they will refund your money. Since undoubtedly they sold the holster to you at a profit, they do not stand to lose as much through their error and learn from the experience themselves.
Good luck,
Ron
__________________
If it's made after 1918...it's a reproduction
|