I would like to thank Alvin for posting two images of a safety area, the first image showing signs of embedded light surface dirt, patina and the 'tiger grain' machine marks'. These are signs of authenticity that the expert eye seeks. Even near mint guns reveal these stuttle signs to in the most tinest degree. For example, look at the grip straps were you MUST notice some patina which comes from normal handling wear.
Believe it or not, I have been collecting for 25 years, however, the majority of my expertise has been gained only in the last 10 years. How come? The reason was that I was not doing my 'homework' properly and I was overlooking the most important factors regarding originality. An European collector further educated me by explaining the true meaning and effects of age which cannot be avoided. Furthermore, he educated me about German quality during the Imperial and Nazi era, and every word that he told me was absolutely true when I saw it for myself. That type of education helped me to understand the 'the good, the bad and the ugly'. It does not take much skill to learn about collecting pistols if you are willing to accept these facts in your observations. I have had the privilage to examined quite a few near mint pistols in museums and private collections, both in the US and Europe, and every single gun which is genuine speaks for itself. When questions or suspicions start to 'pop up', its time to seek opinions from the real and honest experts.
In a subsequent post, Alvin seems to have gone 'over board' using 'surgically precision' (I'm pulling his leg), but the over-riding factor is simply natural aging and handling and the undisutable results that it creates over many, many years. Everything else is 'hog-wash' and it is the notion of time and research which will give meaningful answers. At the end of the day, the final decision lies in the hands of an owner and what standards he/she wants to use to determine authenticity and value.
In regards to German engraving from the early Imperial era, it was very classical and elegant. All the correct presentation Lugers (and Mausers) which I have examined had very fine quality engraving done at the factory and not the deep/chiselled cuts as shown on your pistol.
I hope this information is helpful to you and do not be afraid to ask an expert such as Ron Wood for his inhand examination. I would have gladly provided the (free) service to you, but I am not in the US.
Enjoy the hobby,
Albert
|