Lynn, welcome to the forum! I moved your postings to the New Collectors area.
You have to give us a lot more information for us to help you
Take each gun, hold it in your hands and then write down the information from these sheets;
http://www.lugerforum.com/IDsheets.html
My gut feeling is that one is a P38, but we'll see, at a minimum, we want to know;
What markings are on the top?
What markings are on the left or right?
Caliber?
And can you provide pictures?
I am in the Denver area, so you are about a state away....
Ed
weimar_lugers@comcast.net