M1911 Barrel Bushing Q

[alanint]

Originally Posted by sheepherder

Ace Hardware now stocks assorted Teflon o-rings. I'm tempted to search for a solid M1911 bushing and convert it.

Except that I also favor the Series 70 collet bushing. Yeah, now I remember - that was why I sold the AMT Hardballer with the Teflon bushing.

If by collet bushing you mean the ones with the springy "fingers" that gripped the barrel, they were discontinued because the fingers had a tendency to break off and seriously gum up the works inside the pistol, rendering it inoperable.

[sheepherder]

Originally Posted by alanint

If by collet bushing you mean the ones with the springy "fingers" that gripped the barrel, they were discontinued because the fingers had a tendency to break off and seriously gum up the works inside the pistol, rendering it inoperable.

I've heard that urban myth too. Over the last 3 or 4 decades, I've owned 5 Colt Series 70's w/collet bushings (still have 2) and fitted a 6th bushing to a generic M1911. Never had any problems whatsoever. It's never anyone with firsthand experience writing about it; it's always "my wife's brother's best friend's gardener's cousin's son-in-law's drill sergeant's father" whose bushing broke.

I've never seen any recall notice in any NRA publications or gun magazines, or any announcement from Colt. To my knowledge there has never been any magazine article about the bushings breaking. I would suspect the change back to solid bushing was a cost saving measure.

I would further guess that the Teflon bushing was dropped for the same reason. Too little demand for a more expensive bushing.

On the reamer - They are actually pretty cheap, even for a use-once. I've added one to my next tool purchase list. (It's the 17/32" to 19/32" size)

[Sergio Natali]

Originally Posted by kurusu

Well, One thing I remember, but not 1911 related. Heckler & Koch USP .45 tactical had an o-ring on the barrel front. A friend of mine had one, and it was stupidly accurate.

Originally Posted by sheepherder

I've heard that urban myth too. Over the last 3 or 4 decades, I've owned 5 Colt Series 70's w/collet bushings (still have 2) and fitted a 6th bushing to a generic M1911. Never had any problems whatsoever. It's never anyone with firsthand experience writing about it; it's always "my wife's brother's best friend's gardener's cousin's son-in-law's drill sergeant's father" whose bushing broke.

I've never seen any recall notice in any NRA publications or gun magazines, or any announcement from Colt. To my knowledge there has never been any magazine article about the bushings breaking. I would suspect the change back to solid bushing was a cost saving measure.

I would further guess that the Teflon bushing was dropped for the same reason. Too little demand for a more expensive bushing.

On the reamer - They are actually pretty cheap, even for a use-once. I've added one to my next tool purchase list.

I owned a COLT GOLD CUP NATIONAL MATCH I used it only a few times at the range, then I put it in my safe where it remained for several years, that "collet bushing" was a pain in the neck as apparently it was fairly easy to break it while field stripping the pistol.
I ended trading the pistol not too long ago (and repented straight away). It's still for sale with a gunshop near here.

[alanint]

Originally Posted by sheepherder

I've heard that urban myth too. Over the last 3 or 4 decades, I've owned 5 Colt Series 70's w/collet bushings (still have 2) and fitted a 6th bushing to a generic M1911. Never had any problems whatsoever. It's never anyone with firsthand experience writing about it; it's always "my wife's brother's best friend's gardener's cousin's son-in-law's drill sergeant's father" whose bushing broke.

I've never seen any recall notice in any NRA publications or gun magazines, or any announcement from Colt. To my knowledge there has never been any magazine article about the bushings breaking. I would suspect the change back to solid bushing was a cost saving measure.

A quick google search reveals a whole lot of discussion about the disadvantages of the collet bushing.

https://www.google.com/webhp?sourcei...bushing+issues

[Olle]

Originally Posted by sheepherder

I've heard that urban myth too.

It is also mentioned in the Kuhnhausen manuals, so I don't think it's an urban legend. IIRC, the problem was that they required more precisely machined slides, as they were sensitive to misalignment. If a standard bushing is misaligned, there's usually enough slop in the slide for the barrel to straighten it up, but in a collet bushing it might bend (and eventually break) the fingers instead. Something like that anyway, I can look it up if anybody is interested.

Kuhnhausen recommends replacing them with a solid bushing, but it's "for good measure" so there's no telling how common this problem really was.

[sheepherder]

Originally Posted by Olle

...anyway, I can look it up if anybody is interested...

I'm interested. Others here must be or this thread would have died a natural death...

The comment about it breaking while being removed is new to me.

I just this last couple of months got a couple 1911's back from being blued. Marc says his bushing is a stainless one. I'm not sure I really want to add stainless to an all-blue .45...

[sheepherder]

Hey! I found my .45 barrel bushing reamer!

It got misplaced into, of all places, my drill and ...reamer...drawer...

Kinda grubby looking...Like it got put away without being cleaned...

It's obvious why I couldn't find it...It looks like any other drill tube...