Simson Suhl Luger

[sheepherder]

Originally Posted by Andre'

Looks like this gun has had 4 previous owners; don't know in what time frame but it makes me wonder why?

Often the reason is 'trading up'. Selling the old for a better one.

Or maybe an auctioneer with a great reputation for NOT offering faked Lugers?

Auctioneers are not Luger collectors; they can't be expected to know every little nuance of Luger lore that separates the gems from the fakes. And there is a widespread gentleman's agreement among collectors to NOT broadcast the tips that identify fakes. Or the unique characteristics that identify genuine rare or original Lugers.

Some think this is an exercise in futility, as there are many excellent books with detailed photos of rare/original Lugers pointing out what to look for. There have been many spirited arguments leading to member bans over this subject.

/rant